Hope Joy Golf
  • Welcome Home!
  • Cathy's Blog
    • Tees2Greens Archive Posts >
      • Masters 2020
      • Ryder Cup 2016 Blogs
  • Shop Golf
    • Holiday Gift Ideas for Golfers
    • Product Reviews
    • It's a Deal!! Great Golf Sales

Is Mediocrity Rewarded on Tour? 

1/3/2016

0 Comments

 
Posted Nov 11 2010, 12:08 PM by Cathy Erickson
You know I love Tees2Greens.  But I have to admit that I do visit some other blogs and message boards because we just don't get the golf conversations, debates, and insights on a regular basis here.  (of course I wouldn't trade 2Putt's contributions for the world!!)  Many of the things I ponder and write about here come from those dialogues from other golfers around the web.  What's been on my mind lately is a discussion about which players should be allowed on the PGA Tour.
A fellow contributor at another blog suggested that Tour players who are just out there plugging along at the mid to back of the top 125 pack should be "demoted" back to the Nationwide Tour (or just lose their card) to make room for more players who want to make a run at the best players in the world.  I think the gist of what he was saying is if a guy couldn't make it, not only would he drop off Big Tour, he would actually have to spend a year on another Tour and earn his way back and not just qualify at the end of the season.  If you don't make the Top whatever (50, 75, etc) you're out and those spots open up for Nationwide, q-schoolers, or some other qualifying structure - those hungry for the chance to take on the best in the world.  There's nothing better than naïve optimism is there?
 
I think his point was...no one wants to watch a guy play who's just trying to make the cut and get a paycheck.  We want excitement, and if the stakes are higher you're going to get more drama.  Bring on some more Nationwide Tour guys, allow more q-schoolers to have a chance...maybe there's more Monday qualifiers.  But just get those "journey man" guys out of the way for some more enthusiasm.
 
I, of course, fought against this idea at first.  How is it fair to kick out guys that have toiled and sacrificed to get to the Tour and take away their chance to earn a living?  As a rooter of the underdog, I took offense at the claim that a guy 120th on the money list doesn't go out each week to try to recreate the magic and win another title.  I love the journey man stories!!  Maybe they're not flashy or drawing the spot light, but can we really be asked to believe that there are guys that are just content to be mediocre?  And even if there are, is it really all about creating "the show" for the fans?
 
As I pondered what the goal of the PGA Tour should be, give players a venue to have a career or provide a source of entertainment for golf fans, I don't think you can have one without the other.  The Tour can provide a great living for golfers because corporate sponsors are willing to invest in it...and the only reason they are investing in it is because they want to tap into the fan base that the Tour draws in.
 
The Tour's players and the Tour itself have ridden the wave of success never seen before because fans flocked to see Tiger Woods.  No one really cared about Mr. #125 on the money list, heck, they probably didn't care much about Mr. #10 either.  Everyone jumped on TW's coattails and from what I could tell, it looked like a pretty fun ride.  I'm not saying that the Arnie & Jack days weren't frenzied, but the kind of money involved today makes it a whole different playing field.
 
But now that the high speed "Tiger Train" has been derailed for awhile now, it appears that everyone is finally taking notice of everything and everyone else that makes up the PGA Tour.  And so far, it doesn't seem like we have a real front runner that can provide what Tiger did.   Oh, there are candidates, but none of them have yet proved they've got the staying power that TW seemed to show from the very beginning.
 
So after my immediate defensive response to the idea that the Tour needs to be shaken up, I'm finding myself wondering if maybe there isn't something to the idea that more volatility in the Tour player status could lead to more interest by the fans and more excitement during tournaments.
 
Of course it could backfire.   Many guys in the back of the pack have established fan bases that sponsors and the Tour want to tap into.  And what if you let a college hot-shot that has some buzz on the Tour and then watch him tank week after week because Tour is nothing like a college meet.
 
Or maybe it would help golf exposure to have bigger name players or journey man guys on the Nationwide for a year or two and have them fight back - we love those stories, right?
 
But then I think of the players, who really ARE the Tour...what Tour guy would agree to cut off half of the Tour cards and banish an extra 50-75 players each year?  Maybe the Top 10 guys, but just about everyone else could be Mr. #51 or Mr. #125 next season.
 
I don't know if this is needed, but what I do know is that the more I thought about it the more I wonder if maybe there isn't something to the idea of changing up the structure to give more guys a chance.
 
I'm pretty sure the 400+ guys who are on their way to Stage 2 qualifying next week would love the idea of playing for more spots than the 25 they offer up each year.  What do you think?

Filed under: TIger Woods, Cathy Erickson, Mediocrity, Journey Man, PGA Tour. nationwide tour
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Author

    When I found Tees2Greens website and forum I found a happy place.  There were great people there and in 2009 they asked me if I wanted my own blog space.  It was a dream come true!!  The site is down now, but I was able to get all of my posts to be able to post here.  I will always be grateful for all of the Tees2Greens folks!!

    Archives

    January 2016

    Categories

    All
    2008
    2009
    2010
    2011
    2012
    2013
    2016
    2Putt
    Accessories
    Accident
    Adam Scott
    Alvaro Quiros
    Amy Grant
    Andy Paulson
    Angel Cabrera
    Anonymous Pro
    Anthony Kim
    Apology
    Apparel
    Arizona
    Atlanta
    August
    Augusta National
    Azaleas
    Babe Zaharias
    Back Pain
    Believe
    Benchmark
    Bethpage Black
    Betsy King
    Birdie
    Bobby Jones
    Bob Hope Classic
    Bo Van Pelt
    Brandt Snedeker
    British Open
    Bubba Watson
    Cameron Beckman
    Cathy Erickson
    Celebrate
    Chad Campbell
    Champions Tour
    Character
    Chipshot
    Choices
    Christina Kim
    Christmas
    Clayton Rask
    Comparison
    Competition
    Concentrate
    Concentration
    Confession
    Confidence
    Corporate
    Coverage
    Crystal Golf Ball
    Curling
    Dallas Cowboys
    David Toms
    Davis Love III
    December
    Divot
    Donald Constable
    Don Berry
    Dormie
    Doug Barron
    Dream
    Dreamer
    Dream Team
    Dubai Desert Classic
    Dustin Johnson
    Dwan Golf Club
    Eagle
    Easter
    East Lake
    Economy
    Emotions
    Encouragement
    End Of The Season
    Endorsements
    Enthusiasm
    Equipment
    Erik Compton
    Erik Tammar
    Ernie Els
    Europe
    Excitement
    Expectations
    Eye2
    EZ Links
    Fall
    Fall Series
    Family
    Fan Bus
    Fans
    Fantasy Golf
    FedEx Cup
    Floods
    Focus
    Fred Couples
    Friends
    From The Fringe
    Frustration
    Funk
    Geoff Ogilvy
    Georgia
    Goals
    Golf
    Golf Allowance
    Golf Channel
    Golf Digest
    Golf Fever
    Golf Is Like Life
    Golf Now
    Golf Swing
    Golf Talk
    Gonzo
    Good Good
    Grateful
    Greens
    Greg Norman
    Handicap
    Hang On
    Happiness
    Happy Place
    Hazeltine
    Heart
    Heart Transplant
    Heath Slocum
    Hermitage
    Hockey
    Home Course
    Honda
    Honda Classic
    Honesty
    Hot Ball
    Hotel
    Hunter Mahan
    Hybrid
    Incentive
    Increasing Play
    IOC
    Jason Dufner
    Jeff Rude
    Jerry Kelly
    John Atkinson
    Johnson Wagner
    Jon Sauer
    Journey
    Journeyman
    Juli Inkster
    July
    Junk Points
    Justin Leonard
    Justin Rose
    Justin Smith
    Ken Green
    Kenny Perry
    Kerplookee
    Kodak Challenge
    Lee RInker
    Life
    Limited Status
    LPGA
    Luke Donald
    Lung Cancer
    Magazines
    Majors
    Marathon
    Marc Leishman
    Marketing
    Martin Kaymer
    Masters
    Match Play
    Matt Kuchar
    Media
    Mediocrity
    Memorial
    Memories
    Mental Game
    Merchandise Tent
    Michelle Wie
    Mike Gray
    Minnesota
    Mom & Dad
    Money
    Money List
    Mother Nature
    Motivation
    Municipal
    Nashboro
    Nashville
    Nationwide Tour
    New Year
    Niall Turner
    Nick Watney
    November
    Numbers
    October
    Odds
    Olympics
    Online
    OWGR
    Padraig Harrington
    Passion
    Past
    Pat Bradley
    Patience
    Patty Berg
    Paul Azinger
    Pebble Beach
    Peggy Ference
    PGA
    PGA Championship
    PGA Tour
    Phil Bundy
    Phil Mickelson
    Phoenix
    Player Of The Month
    Players Championship
    Playoff
    Play & Stay
    Points
    Policy
    Potatoes
    Practice
    Practice Round
    Predictions
    President's Cup
    Priorities
    Putter
    Putting
    Q School
    Qualifier
    Queen
    Ranking
    Rant
    Rate
    Refrigerator
    Research & Development
    Resolutions
    Retief Goosen
    Rich Beem
    Rory McIlroy
    Rory Sabbatini
    Routine
    RSM McGladrey
    Rules Of Golf
    Ruling
    Ryder Cup
    Ryo Ishikawa
    Sam Johnson
    Sand Trap
    San Fransisco
    Schmooze
    Scramble
    Sectional
    Senior British Open
    September
    Sergio Garcia
    Seve
    Shark Shootout
    Shazbah
    Shopping
    Si Woo Kim
    Slice
    Solheim Cup
    So-Lo
    Solus
    Sony Open
    Spirit
    Sponsor
    Spring
    Springhouse Golf Club
    Stereotype
    Steve Anderson
    Steve Stricker
    Stress
    Stretch
    Summer
    Super Star
    Tees2greens
    Tennessee
    Texas
    Thankful
    The Classic
    The Golf Club Of Nashville
    The Hermitage
    The Legend
    The Quarry
    The Wilderness
    Thomas Campbell
    Tiger Woods
    Time
    Tips
    Titleist
    Tom Gillis
    Tom Lehman
    Tom Pernice
    Tom Watson
    Top 20
    Top Ten List
    Tour Championship
    Tournament
    Travel
    TV
    Under Par
    USA
    USGA
    US Open
    US Women's Open
    Vacation
    Vaughn Taylor
    Vijay Singh
    Vikings
    Visualize
    Waste Area
    Waste Management Open
    Weather
    Web
    Webb Simpson
    Web.com Tour
    Wedge
    Wednesday
    WGC
    Whistling Straits
    White Tees
    Wind
    Windtree Golf Course
    Winter
    Women In Golf
    YE Yang
    Zach Johnson

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Welcome Home!
  • Cathy's Blog
    • Tees2Greens Archive Posts >
      • Masters 2020
      • Ryder Cup 2016 Blogs
  • Shop Golf
    • Holiday Gift Ideas for Golfers
    • Product Reviews
    • It's a Deal!! Great Golf Sales